31 Spooktacular Halloween Dessert Recipes to Try This Year

halloween dessert recipes are what I’ve been searching for every October, and honestly, finding something new each year is a bit of an Olympic feat. I get stuck between wanting to freak out the kids and make something that’s actually tasty (does anyone really want another dry cupcake with candy eyeballs?). If you’re out there scrolling and debating whether to just hit up the bakery, hang on! I’ve rounded up the most creative ideas that’ll get oohs and aahs from even your most unimpressed friends. Check out more awesome desserts and maybe get a whiff of nostalgia with some Halloween Jello Jigglers while you’re at it. Totally worth it for parties or just late-night munchies.

Edible Arachnids

You want wow factor? Here’s my go-to: creepy-crawly edible spiders! Okay, I’m not gonna lie, these come together faster than a bat out of heck. There’s just something fun (and a little evil) about watching someone bite into one, then realize it’s chocolate and not a tarantula.

Take some chocolate sandwich cookies and pull them apart. Stick on thin pretzel sticks for legs. Scoop on a blob of chocolate frosting, toss on a pair of candy eyes (or white chocolate chips with dots of black gel), and, boom, you have instant eight-legged weirdness.

I used to bring these into my kid’s classroom and—true story—one year I swear the teacher ate five. Not judging, it’s basically the best thing at any party. That salty-sweet combo? Out of this world. If you’d rather go a touch fancier, try dipping the “bodies” in dark chocolate for an upgrade. Double dare: put just a dab of chili powder in the chocolate. Game-changing heat. These definitely beat boring cookies or the basic, make-you-gag licorice spiders. Try them with healthy summer desserts for a fun mash-up!

“I whipped up a batch of these edible arachnids for my office potluck and not only did they vanish fast, but people kept coming back for the recipe. Even my boss—she usually just nibbles carrots!”

Jack-o-Lantern Cream Puffs

If you’re looking for a five-star restaurant vibe with hardly any effort, Jack-o-Lantern Cream Puffs are it. Listen, if you can work a zipper, you can fill a pastry. The trick is using refrigerated dough for the shells if you’re feeling lazy (no shame). Once you’ve baked those up, slice them open and pipe or spoon in whipped cream or pudding. Orange-tinted frosting? That’s your pumpkin face.

The faces don’t have to look like award-winning art. Mine usually turn out more “abstract” than magazine-ready, but honestly, kids love ‘em uglier. I once tried to use jelly for the eyes but let’s just say it was…messy. Pro tip: use a sharp toothpick and black gel icing to draw your Jack-o-Lantern’s grin. If anyone asks, tell them messy is the new chic. These are a must for “spooky but cute” parties. I swear you’ll end up making them all year, not just for Halloween.

Witches Brooms

Okay, this is hands-down the easiest treat on the list and also…just adorable. I make these witches brooms because people always ask if they’re Pinterest-level complicated. Psst: they’re not! You just need mini peanut butter cups, pretzel sticks, and a steadyish hand.

Here’s how I do it:

• Unwrap all the peanut butter cups (and try not to eat half)
• Flip ‘em upside down, poke a pretzel stick gently into the bottom
• If you want, tie a little string of licorice around the top for some flair

That’s pretty much it. Kids can make these basically unsupervised. Heck, my neighbor kid could probably make them with her eyes closed. They’re great for lunchboxes, class parties, or scatter them on a platter for a big Halloween bash. Zero melting, zero fuss, all the oohs.

Dessert Name	Main Ingredients	Difficulty Level	Prep Time
Edible Arachnids	Chocolate cookies, pretzel sticks, chocolate frosting, candy eyes	Easy	15 minutes
Jack-o-Lantern Cream Puffs	Refrigerated dough, whipped cream, orange frosting	Medium	30 minutes
Witches Brooms	Mini peanut butter cups, pretzel sticks, licorice	Easy	10 minutes
Tombstone Treats	Brownies, Milano cookies, black icing	Medium	45 minutes
Halloween Witch Cake	Boxed cake mix, green frosting, candy	Hard	60 minutes

Tombstone Treats

You wanna really get some Halloween drama on the buffet? Make Tombstone Treats. They are basically little graveyards you can eat with your fingers. I use brownies (but cake works if you’re fancy) and cut them into rough rectangles. Frost with chocolate or gray-tinted icing for a dirt effect.

Top each with a Milano cookie or graham cracker “tombstone,” and scrawl R.I.P. with black or white icing. You can also crumble chocolate cookies or wafers for extra mud. Sometimes I get wild and add gummy worms crawling out. It’s a little morbid—my Aunt Carol isn’t a fan—but just about every kid thinks it’s hilarious. If you’re going the extra mile, pipe a rose or a cross on a couple cookies. It’s over-the-top fun without being a giant pain.

These disappear fast at parties. Even grownups sneak extras when they think no one’s watching. Tombstone Treats are the ones people remember, trust me.

Halloween Witch Cake

If you’re in the mood to make something that’s a total show-stopper, this cake is your moment of fame. You don’t have to be a contestant on a baking show. Start with a boxed cake mix (or your favorite homemade recipe, whatever). Layer on some purple or green frosting. Pile on candy eyeballs, black licorice hair, and a sugar cone for the pointy hat.

I like to use leftover Halloween candy to make the features—mini marshmallows for eyeballs, gummy fruit for lips, whatever you have hanging out in the cabinet. You know it’s a success when everyone takes a pic before cutting it. I once tried to make warts with chocolate chips, and they kept rolling down the cake. Still? Looked so spooky.

Keep the design simple. If the “witch” ends up looking like a goblin, congratulations. You nailed the vibe. Slice her up, hand out big slabs, and watch the party go wild for seconds.

Common Questions

Q: How far in advance can I make these halloween dessert recipes?
A: A lot of them you can prep a day ahead. Some, like cream puffs or cakes, actually taste better if you let the flavors mellow a bit. Just keep ‘em sealed.

Q: Are these good for kids to help with?
A: Oh, absolutely. Stuff like Witches Brooms or Edible Arachnids are made for little hands (and maybe big messes).

Q: Can I make spooky desserts without a lot of fancy tools?
A: Yep. Most of these just use household stuff—a spoon, a bowl, or maybe a zip-top bag for piping. No special gadgets needed!

Q: What if I need something allergy-friendly?
A: Skip nuts in Witches Brooms, swap gluten-free treats for brownies or cookies, and use allergy-friendly chocolate if needed. Easy swaps.

Ready for a Spooky, Sweet Night?

Whew, okay, that was a whirlwind! If you’re stuck in a rut for fun halloween dessert recipes, I hope these ideas totally spark your creativity. From easy chocolate pudding to full-on centerpieces, there’s something for every skill level. For even more inspiration, you can browse collections like 68 Best Halloween Dessert Recipes & Ideas | Food Network, 42 SPOOKY AND DELICIOUS HALLOWEEN DESSERT IDEAS …, Over 35 Halloween dessert recipes for your next party!, Sweet and Spooky Halloween Desserts: 41 Frightful Ideas, or 66 Best Halloween Dessert Recipes – Sweets For Halloween Parties. Get baking, snap a few pics, and let me know how yours turn out—bet you won’t have any leftovers!

Print