Melt-in-Your-Mouth Nutella Grilled Cheese Delight

Nutella Grilled Cheese has honestly saved my snack game, especially when I’m just craving something sweet but can’t be bothered to turn on the oven. Ever get home, open the fridge, and stare blankly—hungry, but plain cheese sandwiches sound… well, plain? Yeah, same. That’s when Nutella Grilled Cheese walks in like a delicious superhero. Perfect for lazy Sundays or even a midnight treat. If you’ve tackled a classic grilled cheese sandwich with ground beef or, maybe, gotten wild with a 3-ingredient cottage cheese pizza crust, you’ll want to give this gooey, chocolatey concoction a go. I promise—it’s as easy as pie, but… you know, way faster.

Key Ingredients for Nutella Grilled Cheese

This thing is gloriously simple. I’ve tried fancy stuff before, but honestly, you only need a short list:

Nutella is the undisputed star. No swapping, no “healthy chocolate spread” substitutes.
Softened butter. Just enough to coat the outside of your bread. Makes all the difference.
Good bread is key—personally, I flip-flop between classic white sandwich bread or thick-cut brioche (depends what’s lounging in my bread bin).
A little sprinkle of flaky salt, if you’re feeling fancy. Trust me on this—oddly perfect with sweet stuff.

Sometimes, if I want a little extra, I’ll toss in a few mini marshmallows or banana slices. But the basic combo never lets me down. As weird as it sounds, the salt brings out that chocolate-hazelnut flavor like nothing else.

Honestly, the first time my sister tried it, she said, “There’s no way this is homemade. I would’ve guessed a five-star restaurant did this!” Yep, it’s that good.

Essential Cooking Techniques for Perfecting Your Grilled Cheese

Let’s talk a sec about actually making this sandwich, not just drooling over the idea. Start with preheating your pan on medium—not super hot, not barely warm. If you’re an impatient monster (like me) you might crank the heat. Don’t! You’ll end up with burnt bread and a cold Nutella middle—total heartbreak.

Next, butter the outside of both bread slices. Slam a nice thick layer of Nutella on the inside. Lay your sandwich in the skillet, butter side out. My trick? Place a small lid on top of your sandwich while it cooks. Makes that chocolate center soften up like a dream.

Flip once, gently. Golden brown equals flavor victory. And hey, if there’s a little ooze—don’t panic. It’s basically a Nutella Grilled Cheese rite of passage.

Oh, and don’t get distracted—these brown fast! Stay close for that perfect gooey finish.

Creative Variations of Nutella Grilled Cheese

Once you’ve nailed the basics, it’s stupidly tempting to “jazz things up”—or, in my case, rescue random fruit from the edge of the fridge. Some days, I add sliced strawberries before grilling for a chocolate-strawberry mashup. Bananas are also legendary here. Or swap out white bread for cinnamon swirl loaf—it’s like dessert snuck into dinner.

If you’re braver, add a smear of peanut butter under the Nutella. That’s a Nutella Grilled Cheese that’s simply next-level ridiculous (in the best, sticky-fingers way). Kids go wild for mini marshmallow additions—the sandwich comes out tasting like a warm s’more. Honestly, there’s no wrong way unless you skip the Nutella altogether, then you’re on your own.

Want to feast your eyes on some other wild cheese creations? Peek at my favorite cheese crackers cottage cheese recipe or try the playful cottage cheese wraps if you want something totally different.

Tips for Pairing Sides with Nutella Grilled Cheese

Okay, it sounds obvious, but the right sides just kinda make the whole experience a “thing” instead of a quick snack. Here’s what I like:

• Hot coffee or espresso (if you’re in grown-up mode)
• Simple fruit salad or just sliced bananas if you’re in a rush
• A tiny scoop of vanilla ice cream (dangerously good for dessert nights)
• Sprinkle of toasted nuts, maybe walnuts, gives crunch and grown-up vibes

You don’t need to overthink it. Grab whatever’s nearby—or just eat your Nutella Grilled Cheese solo, because sometimes? It needs no backup.

Ingredient	Quantity	Notes
Nutella	2-3 tablespoons	Use more or less according to taste
Bread	2 slices	Thick-cut brioche or white bread work best
Butter	1 tablespoon	Softened for easy spreading
Flaky Salt	A pinch	Optional, but recommended for flavor
Banana/Strawberries	Optional, to taste	Slices added for extra flavor

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Making Nutella Grilled Cheese

Look, I’ve burned enough bread and suffered limp, soggy sandwiches to know there are pitfalls. First up: impatient heat. Going high just to finish faster? Nah, that’s an instant “regret sandwich.” Keep it on medium.

Don’t overfill with Nutella either, tempting as it is. More filling means more chance of a slippery, messy flop when you flip. Another thing—cheap, flimsy bread will fall apart under Nutella’s weight. Go for sturdy slices. And for the love of all things gooey: DO NOT walk away while it’s on the stove. Even that sixty seconds could mean disaster.

Finally, don’t skip the butter! Dry bread gets sad, fast. Trust me.

Common Questions

Can I make Nutella Grilled Cheese ahead?
Not really. It’s a “cook and eat now” thing. Wait too long, and it just loses its wow.

What’s the best bread for Nutella Grilled Cheese?
Brioche, hands down. But if that’s missing from your kitchen, white sandwich bread works fine.

Can I add other spreads or fruits?
Big yes! Try peanut butter, cream cheese, or bananas for extra flavor.

How do I reheat leftovers?
You technically can, in a toaster oven for crispiness, but it’s really best fresh.

Should I use salted or unsalted butter?
Either works, but salted butter gives you that magic sweet-salty thing I can’t resist.

Ready for the Best Nutella Grilled Cheese Ever?

So there you go—my not-so-perfect, but absolutely delicious, guide to Nutella Grilled Cheese. It’s shockingly simple and sometimes you just want that warm, crispy outside with gooey, melty inside. You get it. If you need inspiration, check out the real-deal Nutella Grilled Cheese Recipe | Epicurious or this fun spin at Nutella Grilled Cheese | Something About Sandwiches. Don’t wait—give it a whirl tonight and let your family think you’re a dessert genius.

Print